The obvious explanation for this is that TV and movie creators fear backlash from pro-lifers. I would suggest that there is another reason the mainstream media promote the anti-abortion point of view. Who sponsors and funds TV shows? Advertisers, of course. It behooves advertisers to have as many potential customers around as possible-- even unwanted children in the foster system will need to be kept in soft drinks and sneakers.
And now—a story. I went to high school in a small town in West Virginia. In our Government class we frequently discussed controversial current events, and every student had to participate. One day that topic was abortion. In our entire large class, only two students—myself and a male student—thought that abortion should remain legal. The teacher challenged the students—what about in the case of rape or incest? What if having the baby would kill the woman? While a couple students waffled at that, the vast majority stayed firm—even in the case of rape, incest, or death of the mother, all abortion should be illegal.
A few years later, I was in college. Once again, small town West Virginia. However, when a professor offhandedly asked the students in one of my classes if anyone believed that abortion should be made across-the-board-illegal, not a single hand went up. I think there is a distinct reason for this. Suddenly hard-line views become a lot more nuanced. Dec 26, Morgan Dhu rated it liked it. Sarah Erdreich's book, The Roe Generation, looks at the current state of reproductive choice access and politics from the perspective of those she calls "the Roe generation - those for whom abortion has always been legal, but has also always been a topic of public discussion and controversy.
Erdreich covers a great deal of territory in this book.
- Seven Stories Press!
- Thailand: Background and U.S. Relations;
- Generation Roe : inside the future of the pro-choice movement in SearchWorks catalog?
- Rubears Christmas in Algonquin Park?
She begins with an overview of the history of abortion in the US, including the role that credentialisation played in the elimination of lay-midwives ex Sarah Erdreich's book, The Roe Generation, looks at the current state of reproductive choice access and politics from the perspective of those she calls "the Roe generation - those for whom abortion has always been legal, but has also always been a topic of public discussion and controversy.
She begins with an overview of the history of abortion in the US, including the role that credentialisation played in the elimination of lay-midwives experienced in abortion from the health care scene and the pro-nativist concern over falling birthrate of white women that lay behind much of the early anti-abortion rhetoric.
Book Review: ‘Generation Roe’ a Savvy New Book By a Young Advocate
Adding context to her research through extensive interviews with interviews with abortion providers, pro-choice activists, non-medical personnel who work in abortion clinics, students considering becoming abortion providers, and others involved in the reproductive rights movement, Erdreich examines such important topics as: - the current state of training around abortion care and contraception in medical schools and the efforts of anti-choice organisations to further erode access to training - strategies used by anti-choice activists to restrict access to abortion through legislation and court challenges that have the long-range goal of overturning Roe v.
Wade - the strong focus on family in anti-choice rhetoric, and how its emphasis on the fetus and on the damage to women from "post abortion syndrome" infantilises women and perpetuates the idea that what everyone really wants is a tradition family focused on child-rearing - media representations of women seeking abortions and the very few instances in popular media where women choose abortion as a valid and positive option. Erdreich concludes her examination of abortion with a critique of established pro-choice organisations as bureaucratic, inflexible, and not prepared to make effective use of modern communications and social media in organising.
She stresses the need for more aggressive planning and action by pro-choice organisations and supporters to turn the tide of increasing barriers and restrictions on abortions, and advocates greater grassroots involvement. Finally, she talks about something every pro-choice supporter can do - help to normalise the idea of abortion rights by discussing it in the same way as any other public policy issue.
Ending the atmosphere of shame and secrecy about reproductive choices is, Erdreich argues, a major step toward being able to see contraception and abortion as normal life issues.
- 7 Poems on Love,Friendship and Betrayal.
- Jewish Culture and Society in North Africa (Indiana Series in Sephardi and Mizrahi Studies).
- Frugal Living 101: Tips on How to Save Money and Stretch a Dollar.
- Parents Who Kill - Shocking True Stories of The Worlds Most Evil Parents.
- Generation Roe: Inside the Future of the Pro-Choice Movement.
- Inside the Future of the Pro-Choice Movement?
Mar 15, S. Smith rated it it was amazing.
Generation Roe is the Abortion Politics Book We've Been Waiting For
Superb overview of current issues facing the reproductive rights movement, including a thorough discussion of legal subjects, medicine, and social attitudes. Erdreich also challenges some of the movement's tactics directly, asking readers to consider what's working and what's not in a text thoroughly grounded by detailed interviews with activists working on the ground and in advocacy organisations.
Mar 20, Shunt27 rated it really liked it. A compelling summary of the current state of reproductive rights, Sarah Erdreich's forthright book will challenge how you think about your role in the fight to make sure every child born in this country can be wanted, healthy and supported. I dare even those who believe themselves ardently pro-choice to read it and not rethink how they can do more to ensure families' rights are protected! May 10, Rose B rated it it was amazing.
Comprehensive look at the past and future of the pro choice movement. Sep 02, Bonnie McDaniel rated it liked it Shelves: non-fiction , feminism , abortion , womens-issues. This little book is a good primer on the state of the pro-choice movement in America. It was written in , long before the recent Supreme Court decision striking down HB 2, Texas' terrible abortion law, and thus is somewhat pessimistic about the movement's future. Despite the recent SCOTUS victory, abortion rights are still under siege in many areas of the country, as this book points out.
Topics include "Hands-Off Training," discussing the lack of training offered by many medical schools i This little book is a good primer on the state of the pro-choice movement in America. Topics include "Hands-Off Training," discussing the lack of training offered by many medical schools in how to perform abortions; " Mis Representations of Reality," pointing out the distorted view of abortions, a common medical procedure 1 in 3 American women has an abortion during her reproductive lifetime , offered on TV and movies; and "I Went to the March for Life, and All I Got Was This Lousy Fear of Choice," the chronicle of the author attending the March for Life and visiting a so-called "Crisis Pregnancy Center.
But I was still shocked at just how factually inaccurate and misleading the abortion information actually was. Just because a clinic is 'faith-based,' as the woman I met with pointed out--to say nothing of not 'abortion-minded'--does not give it the right to provide women and their partners with lies. Well, color me shocked not. This book is well-written but doesn't tackle its subjects in any great depth, unlike another book I recently read on the topic, Katha Pollitt's Pro: Reclaiming Abortion Rights. It's certainly worth reading, however. Aug 15, Kay rated it liked it.
Erdreich does a great job of putting the modern pro-choice movement into context.
Though I think the book contained lots of useful information, I'd say one of the failings from my perspective is that lots of this information is stuff I'm already pretty familiar with, given how much time I've spent reporting on these issues. I also wished she spend more time delving into the poling information and focus groups to talk about the generational shifts in the pro-choice movement. She spends much of th Erdreich does a great job of putting the modern pro-choice movement into context. She spends much of that chapter relating quotes from interviews with leaders in the pro-choice movement of different generations -- useful, for sure, but I would've loved to see it pared with hard numbers.
And through no fault of Erdreich's own, much has happened in the abortion debate since her book went to press. One of the best parts of this book was about the abortion providers. She talks to medical students about the barriers to becoming an abortion provider. For many, it's not just that those on their way to becoming doctors have to largely opt in to learning about the procedure and, shockingly, spend only about an hour in medical school discussing it , but it's also about deciding what kind of medical practitioner they want to become.
Because abortion has become so politicized, there are so few providers. This means that those who do choose to become abortion providers end up only performing abortions. It is these early chapters where the book really shines. Ultimately this was a well-researched and thoughtful look at the pro-choice movement.
It's an ongoing story, one that is far from finished. Jul 25, Laura Ellyn rated it really liked it. Why shouldn't abortion be just one more subject that friends and acquaintances can discuss in casual settings, on casual occasions? Treating abortion like just another controversial topic demystifies it, makes it less of a capital-T topic; it removes that whole "movie of the week" vibe that so many people still associate with addressing controversial and personal topics.
Further thoughts: I bought this mostly on impulse and wasn't really expecting much, but it's a solid piece of reporting that does what it sets out to do. I think more books like this are needed.
Mar 25, Diana rated it it was amazing Shelves: non-fiction. Brilliant and thought-provoking, this concise yet thorough history of the pro-choice movement touches on topics and issues that even the most adamant of reproductive choice proponents may have overlooked or short-changed. Galvanizing and poignant, rather than only rattling sabers and shouting slogans, Erdreich's book encourages conversation as well as action, that all thougtful and caring people may arrive at an understanding of the rightful role of reproductive freedom in the strength of the American family and the fabric of democracy.
Jul 17, Elizabeth Gray rated it really liked it. Abortion is a complicated issue, and forty years after Roe v Wade, this book was was written to explore the issues surrounding abortion. It is mentioned in the book that the anti-choice movement has realized that if there are no qualified doctors performing abortions, the procedure will not be done. The book goes into detail the hoops medical students must go through in order to perform abortions legally.
In bringing up the case against Kermit Gosnell, the book suggests that instead of addressin Abortion is a complicated issue, and forty years after Roe v Wade, this book was was written to explore the issues surrounding abortion. In bringing up the case against Kermit Gosnell, the book suggests that instead of addressing the fact that there were so many poor women who could not afford to go anywhere but to an unsafe practitioner, the state of Pennsylvania simply passed reactive anti-choice laws.
Chapter of note on how abortion is portrayed in media, and how many viewers are reached. The book also goes into the apathy that makes it possible for anti-choice laws to be passed, and muses on the future of the pro-choice movement. A few particularly harsh years of abortion restrictions at the federal and state level have blossomed into a season of new, unapologetically pro-choice books about abortion rights. Yes, the book is informative and you will learn quite a few things.
Abortion is, for the women who experience it, ambiguous. Abortion is emotionally complex. The pro-choice movement cannot expect to survive if it does not allow every kind of story to be told, even the ones that cause others to examine their own values and biases. Simply framing abortion as a sad or otherwise regrettable choice is capitulating to the anti-choice messaging, which holds that every abortion is a mistake and every woman suffers.
As Erdreich points out, many young activists are doing just this, often using social media.pl.inijohiv.tk
Generation roe : inside the future of the pro-choice movement
She argues that talking more openly about real experiences with abortion and reproductive health care, both at individual and institutional levels, will help to dispel the idea that abortion is always bad and will allow the movement to play offense as well as defense. Further, she argues that advocates need to stop allowing one side to talk about children and the other side to talk about women; Erdreich writes that abortion rights advocates need to talk about both.
At the same time, I had some additional hopes for the book. Toward the end she argues for more autonomy and funding for local organizations working within the movement, which would be helpful, but I found myself wishing she would have directly made more suggestions about changes that can be made to keep advocates more nimble and in-step with the times at the national level as well. Perhaps this was due to publishing timelines, which would be a bummer.
Related Generation Roe: Inside the Future of the Pro-Choice Movement
Copyright 2019 - All Right Reserved